Cartoon of the Year
Western Animation Exclusive
2024 Winner - Arcane (Season 2)
Runner up: Smiling Friends (Season 2)
3rd Place Tie: X-Men '97 (Season 1)
Results - Jordan (1st), Tyler (1st), Chris (1st), Juan (1st), John (1st)
2023 Winner - My Adventures with Superman (Season 1)
Runner up: Invincible (Season 2 Part 1)
3rd Place: Scott Pilgrim Takes Off
Results - Eddie (1st), Tevin (1st), Juan (1st), Tyler (1st), Jordan (2nd)
2022 Winner - Smiling Friends (Season 1)
Runner up: Rick & Morty (Season 6)
3rd Place: The Boys: Diabolical
Results - Eddie (1st), Chris (1st), Tevin (1st), Tyler (1st), Jordan (1st), Berto (2nd)
2021 Winner - Invincible (Season 1)
Runner up: Arcane
3rd Place: Rick & Morty (Season 5)
Results - Troy (1st), Justin (1st), Jordan (1st), Kyle (1st), Chris (1st), Tevin (1st), Tyler (2nd), Juan (3rd)
2020 Winner - Star Wars: The Clone Wars (Final Season)
Runner up: Bojack Horseman (Season 6 Part 2)
3rd Place Tie: Ducktales (Season 3) / Animaniacs (Season 1)
Results - Jordan (1st), Tyler (1st), Eddie (1st), Tevin (1st), Adrian (1st), Berto (1st), Juan (2nd)
2019 Winner - Bojack Horseman (Season 6 Part 1)
Runner up: South Park (Season 23)
3rd Place: Rick & Morty (S4E1-S4E5))
Results - Chris (1st), Juan (1st), Tevin (1st), Jordan (1st)
2018 Winner - Castlevania (Season 2)
Runner up Tie: Bojack Horseman (Season 5) / Star Wars Rebels (Season 4 Part 2)
Results - Eddie (1st), Kyle (1st), Ike (1st), Berto (1st), Tevin (2nd)
2017 Winner - Samurai Jack (Season 5)
Runner up: Rick & Morty (Season 3)
3rd Place: Castlevania (Season 1)
Results - Juan (1st), Ike (1st), Eddie (1st), Berto (2nd)
2016 Winner - Bojack Horseman (Season 3)
Runner up: Star Wars Rebels (Season 2/3)
3rd Place: South Park (Season 20)
Results - Jordan (1st), Juan (1st), Tyler (1st), Chris (1st)
2015 Winner - Rick & Morty (Season 2)
Runner up: N/A
3rd Place: N/A
Results - Wheeling (1st), Grim (1st)
2014 Winner - Rick & Morty (Season 1)
Runner up: Bojack Horseman (Season 1)
3rd Place: Star Wars The Clone Wars (Season 6)
Results - Wheeling (1st), Tyler (1st), Kyle (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st), Troy (1st)
2013 Winner - Star Wars The Clone Wars (Season 5)
Runner up: N/A
3rd Place: N/A
Results - Tyler (1st), Tevin (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st)
2012 Winner - Star Wars The Clone Wars (Season 4)
Runner up: N/A
3rd Place: N/A
Results - Tyler (1st), Tevin (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st)
2011 Winner - Beavis and Butthead (Season 8)
Runner up: Star Wars The Clone Wars (Season 4)
3rd Place: N/A
Results - Wheeling (1st), Eddie (1st), Jordan (2nd), Juan (2nd)
2010 Winner - Regular Show (Season 1/2)
Runner up: N/A
3rd Place: N/A
Results - Jordan (1st), Tevin (1st), Berto (1st), Wheeling (1st)
2009 Winner - Spectacular Spider-Man (Season 2)
Runner up: Chowder (Season 2)
3rd Place: Star Wars The Clone Wars (Seasons 1/2)
Results - Tyler (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st), Tevin (1st)
2008 Winner - Avatar The Last Airbender (Book 3 Part 2)
Runner up: Spectacular Spider-Man (Season 1)
3rd Place: Flapjack (Season 1)
Results - Eddie (1st), Juan (1st), Tevin (1st), Tyler (2nd)
2007 Winner - Avatar The Last Airbender (Book 3 Part 1)
Runner up: Danny Phantom (Season 3)
3rd Place: The Boondocks (Season 2)
Results - Tyler (1st), Juan (1st), Tevin (1st)
2006 Winner - Avatar The Last Airbender (Book 2)
Runner up: Danny Phantom (Season 2)
3rd Place: The Boondocks (Season 1)
Results - Juan (1st), Tevin (1st), Tyler (2rd)