Game of the Year
2024 Winner - Marvel Rivals
Runner up: Astro Bot
3rd Place: Final Fantasy VII Rebirth
Results - John (1st), Kyle (1st), Eddie (1st), Berto (1st), Jordan (1st), Tyler (2nd), Juan (3rd)
2023 Winner - The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
Runner up: Spider-Man 2
3rd Place: Star Wars Jedi Survivor
Results - Eddie (1st), Jordan (1st), Berto (1st), Juan (2nd)
2022 Winner - God of War: Ragnarok
Runner up: Elden Ring
3rd Place: TMNT: Shredder's Revenge
Results - Juan (1st), Tyler (1st), Tevin (1st), Berto (2nd), Jordan (2nd)
2021 Winner - Halo Infinite
Runner up: Metroid Dread
3rd Place: Guardians of the Galaxy
Results - Juan (1st), Jordan (1st), Berto (1st), Eddie (2nd), Kyle (2nd)
2020 Winner - Ghost of Tsushima
Runner up: Spider-Man: Miles Morales
3rd Place: Final Fantasy VII Remake
Results - Tyler (1st), Tevin (1st), Mike (1st), Berto (1st), Eddie (2nd)
2019 Winner - Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order
Runner up: Kingdom Hearts III
3rd Place: Devil May Cry V
Results - Kyle (1st), Juan (1st), Tevin (1st), Troy (1st), Eddie (2nd), Mike (3rd), Tyler (3rd)
2018 Winner - Spider-Man
Runner up: Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
3rd Place: God of War
Results - Tevin (1st), Kyle (1st), Berto (1st), Troy (1st), Tyler (1st), Justin (1.5th), Eddie (2nd), Mike (2nd), Juan (2nd), John (2nd), Wheeling (2nd), Jordan (3rd)
2017 Winner - Super Mario Odyssey
Runner up: Nier Automata
3rd Place: The Legend of Zelda Breath of the Wild
Results - Mike (1st), Kyle (1st), Berto (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (2nd), Wheeling (2nd), Eddie (3rd), Tevin (3rd), John (3rd)
2016 Winner - Overwatch
Runner up: Doom
3rd Place Tie: Ratchet & Clank / Uncharted 4
Results - Eddie (1st), Jordan (1st), Joh (1st), Kyle (1st), Berto (1st), Wheeling (2nd), Mike (2nd)
2015 Winner - Rocket League
Runner up: Metal Gear Solid V
3rd Place: Batman Arkham Knight
Results - Mike (1st), Wheeling (1st), Eddie (1st)
2014 Winner - Super Smash Bros. WiiU
Runner up: Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor
3rd Place: Mario Kart 8
Results - Mike (1st), Kyle (1st), Jordan (1st), Eddie (1st), Juan (3rd)
2013 Winner - Grand Theft Auto V
Runner up: Bioshock Infinite
3rd Place: Metal Gear Rising
Results - Wheeling (1st), Tyler (1st), Tevin (1st), Kyle (2nd), Jordan (2nd), Juan (2nd)
2012 Winner - Mass Effect 3
Runner up: Halo 4
3rd Place: Call of Duty Black Ops II
Results - Wheeling (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st), Tevin (2nd), Eddie (3rd)
2011 Winner - Skyrim
Runner up: Batman Arkham City
3rd Place: Marvel vs Capcom 3
Results - Wheeling (1st), Tevin (1st), Mike (1st), Kyle (1st), Jordan (2nd), Juan (3rd)
2010 Winner - Mass Effect 2
Runner up: Halo Reach
3rd Place: Assassin's Creed Brotherhood
Results - Jordan (1st), Juan (1st), Tevin (1st), Kyle (1st), Wheeling (1st), Eddie (2nd)
2009 Winner - Assassin's Creed 2
Runner up: Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2
3rd Place: Uncharted 2
Results - Tyler (1st), Juan (1st), Mike (1st), Jordan (2nd)
2008 Winner - Metal Gear Solid 4
Runner up: Gears of War 2
3rd Place: Left 4 Dead
Results - Tevin (1st), Adrian (1st), Mike (1st), Tyler (2nd)
2007 Winner - Halo 3
Runner up: Call of Duty 4 Modern Warfare
3rd Place: Mass Effect
Results - Eddie (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st), Tevin (1st), Berto (1st)
2006 Winner - Kingdom Hearts II
Runner up: Gears of War
3rd Place: Marvel Ultimate Alliance
Results - Eddie (1st), Jordan (1st), Tevin (1st), Mike (1st), Juan (2nd), Tyler (3rd)
2005 Winner - Resident Evil 4
Runner up: Star Wars: Battlefront II
3rd Place: Guitar Hero
Results - Eddie (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st), Tyler (2nd)
2004 Winner - Halo 2
Runner up: Metal Gear Solid 3
3rd Place: Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Results - Berto (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st)
2003 Winner - The Legend of Zelda: The Windwaker
Runner up: Pokemon Ruby & Sapphire
3rd Place: Tony Hawk's Underground
Results - Eddie (1st), Juan (1st)
2002 Winner - Kingdom Hearts
Runner up: Sly Cooper: Thievius Raccoonus
3rd Way Tie: Metroid Fusion / Grand Theft Auto: Vice City / Animal Crossing
Results - Berto (1st), Mike (1st), Jordan (1st), Juan (1st), Eddie (2nd)
2001 Winner - Super Smash Bros. Melee
Runner up: Halo: Combat Evolved
3rd Place: Luigi's Mansion
Results - Eddie (1st), Mike (1st), Adrian (1st)
2000 Winner - Spider-Man
Runner up: Pokemon Stadium
3rd Place: Spyro: Year of the Dragon
Results - Juan (1st), Tevin (1st TIE), Tyler (2nd)